Word problems: draw the story before choosing the calculation
Name: _________________________ Date: ______________
For the designed pupil sheets with writing space, use the downloadable four-page PDF on the article page.
Page 1: Pupil activity
Same numbers. Different stories.
Read each story. Who has more? What do you know? What must you find? Use a drawing,
objects, an equation or words. Label your answer in counters.
1. Amina has 24 counters. She has 6 more counters than Joseph. How many
counters does Joseph have?
Draw, write or explain your thinking.
2. Amina has 24 counters. Joseph has 6 more counters than Amina. How
many counters does Joseph have?
Draw, write or explain your thinking.
Both stories say “6 more”. Why are the answers different? Include who has more in your
explanation.
Page 2: Pupil activity
Change the question. Keep the story.
3. Amina has some counters. She has 6 more than Joseph. Joseph has 18
counters. How many counters does Amina have?
Draw, write or explain your thinking.
How does this connect to question 1? Explain what is known and what is unknown in each.
Optional: equal groups
4. Share 24 counters equally among 6 children. How many counters does each child receive?
5. Put 24 counters into groups of 6. How many groups can you make?
Show both stories. Label what each number means.
The answers have the same number. Are they answers to the same question? Explain “four of
what”.
Page 3: Teacher notes
Listen for the relationship
Core: addition and subtraction within 100. Allow about 15 minutes. Questions 4–5 are optional
and require equal-group understanding. Read stories aloud and accept spoken explanations.
1. Joseph has 18 counters
Amina is the person with more. Joseph + 6 = 24; 24 - 6 = 18. Check: 18 + 6 = 24. A comparison
bar can show the relationship:
Amina
18
6
Joseph
18
2. Joseph has 30 counters
Now Joseph has more. 24 + 6 = 30. Check: 30 - 24 = 6. The words “more” do not tell us which
amount is unknown.
Joseph
24
6
Amina
24
3. Amina has 24 counters
18 + 6 = 24. This is the same relationship as question 1. In question 1 Joseph’s smaller amount
is unknown; here Amina’s larger amount is unknown.
A correct number alone is not enough evidence. Ask pupils to identify the larger amount,
explain the difference, and check their answer in the story.
Page 4: Teacher notes
Use the answers to choose a next step
Model the reasoning
Try: “I know Amina has 24. She has more, so Joseph must have fewer than 24. I can remove the extra 6
to find Joseph’s amount.” Show objects or a labelled sketch. Drawings are a tool, not compulsory
evidence if a pupil explains clearly.
If question 1 gets 30
Ask “Who has more? Would Joseph having 30 fit this story?” It may be a language misunderstanding,
calculation slip or keyword habit. Read it aloud, compare two piles and ask again; do not diagnose from
one response.
Optional answers: four of what?
4: 4 counters per child, because 6 equal shares of 4 total 24. 5: 4 groups, because 4 groups of 6 total 24.
Both use 24 divided by 6; what the 6 and the 4 represent changes.
Support and stretch
Use smaller amounts and objects if needed. Let pupils rehearse in a familiar language. For more
challenge, ask them to write a new story with the same relationship but a different unknown. Check it
makes sense before swapping with a partner.
Revisit without the original numbers
Another day: “Leah has 35 counters, 8 more than Tom. How many does Tom have?” Answer: 27
counters. Also ask: “Tom has 27 counters. Leah has 8 more than Tom. How many does Leah have?”
Answer: 35. Mix the order; ask who has more and check both explanations.
Background and use
Approach informed by EEF maths guidance and Powell & Fuchs (2018), linked in the article. These
original activities have not been classroom-trialled. Print, copy and adapt for your teaching; credit