SkillFlex
← All resources
Maths

Word problems: draw the story before choosing the calculation

Two stories say “6 more”. Why do they need different calculations?

Amina has 24 counters. She has 6 more than Joseph. How many does Joseph have? Now try this: Amina has 24 counters. Joseph has 6 more than Amina. How many does Joseph have?

Both stories use 24, 6 and “more”. The answers are 18 and 30. Choosing an operation from a keyword can hide the relationship pupils need to understand. This short activity makes that relationship the centre of the conversation.

Start with the story

Before calculating, ask: Who has more? Which amount do we know? Which amount are we finding? Should the answer be larger or smaller than 24? Give pupils thinking time, then invite a sketch, two rows of counters, an equation or a spoken explanation. A drawing is an option, not a compulsory method.

Model the first problem aloud: “Amina has more, so Joseph must have fewer than 24. The extra 6 is part of Amina’s amount. Removing that extra part leaves 18.” Check by adding it back: 18 + 6 = 24. In the second story Joseph has more, so his amount is 24 + 6 = 30.

Change what is unknown

Keep the relationship but change the question: “Amina has some counters, 6 more than Joseph. Joseph has 18. How many does Amina have?” The answer is 24. Ask pupils to explain how this connects to the first story. The aim is to understand the three quantities, rather than learn another trigger word.

Four of what?

The optional extension contrasts sharing 24 counters among 6 children with making groups of 6 counters. Both give 4, but one means four counters per child and the other means four groups. Ask pupils to label the unit. Use this part only when they understand equal groups; it is not needed for the core comparison task.

Let the response guide your next question

If a pupil gives 30 for Joseph in the first story, ask whether Joseph having 30 fits Amina having more. A mistake might reflect language, calculation or a keyword habit. One answer does not establish which. Read aloud, use objects and invite pupils to retell the relationship in a familiar language if helpful.

Later, revisit with new numbers: Leah has 35 counters, 8 more than Tom. Tom has 27. Reverse the unknown too: Tom has 27 and Leah has 8 more; Leah has 35. Mix the order and check both relationships. Look for an explanation that still works when the numbers change, not speed or a particular drawing style.

Use the pack

Allow about 15 minutes. The core assumes addition and subtraction within 100. Print pages 1–2 for pupils; pages 3–4 contain answers, optional bar representations and response-specific teaching notes. If calculation needs attention, try our subtraction resource separately.

Further reading

These sources inform the approach; they do not evaluate or endorse this original SkillFlex activity.

Free to print, copy and adapt for teaching. Credit SkillFlex when redistributing; not for resale. Original fictional examples, not yet classroom-trialled.

← Find another classroom idea

Curious about SkillFlex?

Alongside these free resources, SkillFlex offers maths and English practice for primary schools.

See how SkillFlex works · Request a school demo