A pupil can calculate 8 + 4 and still put 12 in the box in 8 + 4 = □ + 5. The calculation is correct; the equation is not. This activity makes the meaning of equality visible.
Start with meaning
Read the whole equation aloud as “eight plus four has the same value as something plus five”. Work out the left side, then ask what the right side needs to total. Seven plus five is twelve. Substituting the answer is a useful check rather than a separate trick.
Compare and explain
Include equations with a number on the left and addition on the right, such as 9 = 4 + 5. Ask whether turning the equation around changes its truth. Compare totals using objects if needed. Avoid treating the equals sign as an instruction to do whatever calculation came before it.
Make the next question count
The optional challenge changes one addend while preserving the total: 27 + 15 = 28 + □. The box is fourteen. Use it only when pupils are ready for the larger numbers. For everyone, a later fresh example is more informative than repeatedly completing the same pattern.
What is in the pack?
One pupil sheet and one teacher sheet, with checked examples, support and a fresh revisit task. Use the tasks flexibly and choose by prior understanding. Oral answers and objects can help separate conceptual understanding from reading or handwriting demands.
These are original teaching activities, not claims of measured learning gains. A pupil’s answer should guide a follow-up question, not become a permanent label.
Further reading
NCETM: equivalence and compensation provides related teaching background. These original SkillFlex tasks are not an endorsed or evaluated programme.
Free to print, copy and adapt for teaching with credit to SkillFlex. Not for resale. Original activities, not yet classroom-trialled.
