Read the comment as a pupil
“Be more careful” may be well meant, but it does not identify where to look or what to change. Before writing a comment, imagine receiving it without the teacher beside you. Could you take a useful next step? The printable contrasts vague comments with more specific directions. This is not a scoring system for teachers; it is a short way to discuss whether feedback can lead to action.
Point without doing the thinking
“Check whether three minibuses provide enough pupil seats” directs attention to a relationship. Writing the final answer beside the work removes that decision. A useful prompt still depends on what the pupil knows. If the task itself has not been taught clearly, another question may be less helpful than a brief explanation and model. Feedback is not a substitute for instruction.
Separate acknowledgement from the next step
Specific acknowledgement can show a pupil what already works. A next step should be distinguishable from that acknowledgement. “Your drawing shows both groups; now explain which has more” is an example only when the actual work supports it. Do not paste generic praise or invent a misconception. The activity asks teachers to state what they would need to know about the work before choosing a comment.
Make space for the response
Allow time to act, with the length matched to the task. Five minutes may suit a small correction but is not a universal prescription. The response slip asks what changed and what the pupil will check next. An oral response or showing the revision may be more suitable than another written form. Where many pupils need the same guidance, a shared explanation may be clearer than many individual comments. Judge the response, not the quantity of marking. Keep this distinct from our exit tickets: it is about what happens after feedback is given.
Research and further reading
Established EEF feedback guidance; original staff activity, not a claim of guaranteed gains or time savings.
Original SkillFlex activity prepared with AI assistance and editorial checks; not classroom-trialled. Sources inform the approach, not endorsement. Free to print, copy and adapt for teaching with credit to SkillFlex. Not for resale.
