SkillFlex
← All resources
Reading

Reading inference: questions that ask for evidence

An original short story, five questions and suggested answers to help pupils separate what a text says from what its clues suggest.

Who it is for: Pupils who can follow a short narrative, independently or read aloud; often Years 3–5. Allow: 15–20 minutes. Choose by what your pupils already know, rather than age alone.

“She is worried.” That might be a good inference, but what in the story supports it? Asking pupils to point to a clue turns an impression into a reading conversation.

An inference is an interpretation supported by the text and relevant knowledge. It is not a licence to invent any explanation. Some questions have more than one defensible answer; others cannot be settled from the available information. This resource makes room for both.

Read this short story together

Amina reached the classroom with a paper bag held carefully against her chest. She put it beneath her chair and checked that it was upright. When Mr Kato asked for the seedlings, she looked at the floor. “Mine looked different this morning,” she said. At break, Musa brought a small cup of water. Together they lifted the bag onto the table. One thin stem leaned over the edge of its pot. “Let's put it by the window and ask what it needs,” Musa said. Amina loosened her grip on the bag.

Model the difference between a fact and an inference

First ask where Amina puts the bag. “Beneath her chair” is stated directly. Then ask how she might feel when the seedlings are requested. Worry or uncertainty is plausible because she looks at the floor and says her plant looked different. The text does not name her emotion.

Think aloud briefly: “I noticed this detail. It makes me think this might be happening.” Avoid supplying every interpretation before pupils have had time to think.

Use five questions

  1. Where does Amina put the bag?
  2. How might Amina feel when Mr Kato asks for the seedlings? Which detail supports your answer?
  3. What suggests Musa wants to help?
  4. Do we know why the stem is leaning? Explain.
  5. What might Amina loosening her grip suggest? Could there be another explanation?

The fourth question matters. A leaning stem does not prove that the plant needs water. Musa brings water, but the story does not establish the cause or the correct treatment. Pupils can suggest a possibility while recognising what remains unknown.

Listen for the link, not a particular adjective

A pupil who says “embarrassed” may have a reasonable explanation, even if your first thought was “worried”. Ask them to link the word to a detail. If an answer adds an unseen argument or an event the story never mentions, ask which part of the text supports it.

“I think ___ because the text says ___” is a helpful starting frame, but do not let it become a copying exercise. Ask how the chosen detail supports the idea. Sometimes an accurate paraphrase is clearer than a long quotation.

Make the reading accessible

If the aim is inference, you can read the passage aloud, explain “seedling”, and allow an oral response. That checks comprehension with support; it is not evidence that the pupil can read the passage independently. For more challenge, compare two possible interpretations and decide which has stronger support.

Use the vocabulary routine when an unfamiliar word gets in the way. Revisit inference with a different passage later, rather than assuming success on one story transfers automatically.

Further reading

EEF: reading comprehension strategies provides background on this teaching approach. The activities and examples here are original SkillFlex resources, not an endorsed programme or a tested intervention.

Use and share: You may print, copy and adapt this original activity for your own teaching. Please share the article link with colleagues and credit SkillFlex when redistributing an adaptation. Do not sell the resource or imply endorsement by the organisations cited.

← Find another classroom idea

Curious about SkillFlex?

Alongside these free resources, SkillFlex offers maths and English practice for primary schools.

See how SkillFlex works · Request a school demo