SkillFlex
← All resources
Maths

Subtraction: change the grouping, not the number

A short place-value activity that makes exchanging visible, with a worked example, pupil questions and teacher answers.

Who it is for: Pupils who can partition two-digit numbers into tens and ones; often Years 2-3. Allow: 15-20 minutes. Choose by pupils' prior learning rather than age alone.

Why does the ten become ten ones?

A pupil may complete a column subtraction by crossing out digits without knowing why the value stays the same. Before adding more calculations, ask one question: how else could we show 42? The aim is to connect the written steps with a quantity pupils can see, not to teach a crossing-out trick.

Start with a number you can build

Make 42 using four bundles of ten sticks and two loose sticks. Ask a pupil to open one bundle. There are now three tens and twelve ones, but there are still 42 sticks. Draw both arrangements and write 40 + 2 = 30 + 12. If bundles are unavailable, draw a long bar for each ten and a dot for each one. Explain what each mark represents.

Show what changes in 42 - 17

Start with 42, not with two piles that might be added together. Exchange one ten for ten ones, then remove seven ones and one ten. You have two tens and five ones: 25. Keep the removed objects apart. Write each step beside the model so pupils can connect the digits to the tens and ones. Ask: did exchanging change how many we started with?

Use a wrong answer to reveal a useful idea

The printable includes a fictional answer of 35 for 52 - 27. Ask pupils to test it, rather than guess which rule was broken. Adding 35 and 27 gives 62, not 52. Building 52 and removing 27 gives 25. A pupil who subtracts the smaller digit from the larger in each column may need another look at what the whole subtraction means. Avoid saying that 2 minus 7 is impossible: here, we are regrouping a positive whole number to carry out the written calculation.

Choose the next question carefully

Compare 64 - 32 with 64 - 38. The first needs no exchange in the ones column; the second does. Ask pupils to predict before calculating, then check their predictions with a model. A correct answer alone does not show that a pupil understands the exchange. Ask them to explain why five tens and fourteen ones still make 64.

Support, challenge and a check tomorrow

For support, work with one calculation and ready-made bundles. Let pupils explain by pointing or speaking before writing. For challenge, compare exchanging with counting up from 38 to 64 and discuss which method feels efficient. Do not add hundreds and zeros until the two-digit structure is secure. The next day, use 53 - 26: ask for the exchange, the answer and an addition check. Use the response to plan the next lesson, not to label a pupil.

Further reading

NCETM: place value and exchanging in subtraction offers background on the teaching approach. These activities, texts and examples are original SkillFlex work, not an endorsed programme or a tested intervention.

Use and share: Print, copy and adapt for your own teaching. Please credit SkillFlex and share the article link when redistributing an adaptation. Do not sell the resource or imply endorsement by the organisations cited.

← Find another classroom idea

Curious about SkillFlex?

Alongside these free resources, SkillFlex offers maths and English practice for primary schools.

See how SkillFlex works · Request a school demo